Dade’s Massacre Recalls Seminole History

BUSHNELL — During the first weekend of January, hundreds gather from around the country to re-create an event that forever changed the face of Florida.

It was late December 1835, and the U.S. government planned to begin its Indian removal in just a few days. One hundred and eight soldiers, under the command of Major Francis Dade, had been dispatched from Fort Brooke (near Tampa) to reinforce the troops at Fort King, who were being threatened by Chief Osceola.

Dade's Massacre

Dade’s Massacre

After six days of arduous hiking, the soldiers were looking forward to a late Christmas. But on the chilly morning of December 28, just 40 miles short of their goal, they relaxed their guard.  In the scrub forest ahead, 200 Seminole warriors under the command of Chief Jumper crouched beneath the palmettos.

As the troops filed past two abreast, the Seminoles opened fire. Half fell in that first volley, including Major Dade. The remaining troops scrambled for cover and managed to construct a log breastwork, but their efforts were in vain. By the day’s end, only three U.S. soldiers would be left alive.

Frank Laumer at Dade's Battle

Frank Laumer at Dade’s Battle

Historian Frank Laumer described the battle as a watershed in Florida history. The Seminoles “made a terrible mistake” by defeating the U.S. Army in broad daylight, Laumer said. “That was an affront that simply couldn’t be born according to the honor system of the time.”

Laumer is the author of two books on the battle: Massacre and Dade’s Last Command. Laumer believes that if the Seminoles had not won Dade’s Battle, they might still own the southern half of Florida. “It was considered a pestilential place, full of mosquitoes alligators and Indians. People termed it the most miserable place they ever saw.”

Instead, “Dade’s Massacre” became the first battle of the Second Seminole War. The war would last seven years, cost $40 million (in historic dollars) and take the lives of 1,500 U.S. soldiers. By the war’s end, about 5,000 Indians were sent to the Oklahoma Territory.

“It seems clearly revealed to me now that the cause of this whole fracas was the slavery issue,” Laumer said. Escaped slaves from found acceptance and relative freedom among the Seminoles, but the government wanted them back. The Indian removal policy was a means of sifting out the escaped slaves.

Laumer was originally drawn to the story of Dade’s Battle by reading the account of Ransom Clarke, one of only three U.S. soldiers who survived.
Clarke suffered a shattered pelvis, a broken arm, a bullet in his lungs, and a severe head wound, but he crawled 60 miles to Fort
Brooke in three days. The story sounded incredible to Laumer, so he had Clarke’s body exhumed to verify the wounds.

Seminole Warrior at Dade's Battlefield

Seminole Warrior at Dade’s Battlefield

“I try to think and feel as that man must have, as I stand there in full uniform and narrate the battle that is going on full volume behind me,” Laumer said. In spite of the terror of the day, Laumer said he’s affected most by Clarke’s courage: “This is a man who did not know how to give up.”

Those who reenact the event take pride in the authenticity of their clothing as well as their portrayal of the battle. The weekend’s activities include authentic Seminole and U.S. Army encampments, Seminole dances, and native American crafts.

“What we’re wearing is historically documented and accurate 1830s Seminole clothing,” said Earl DeBary of Ocala. He researched his own colorful outfit by studying first-hand accounts of the period.

The part of Chief Jumper was portrayed in battle scenes by Paul Morrison of Leesburg, who also directed the battle. Morrison, whose ancestry is part Seminole, has performed Seminole history programs in schools. When he helped start the Dade’s Battle reenactments, it was the fulfillment of a life-long dream. “I’d always say a prayer that I wanted to do that battle someday, but I didn’t want to shoot real bullets.”

Morrison said the Seminoles acted, in part, to establish respect. “A lot of people who knew the Seminole said we were timid and cowardly,” he explained.  “Andrew Jackson said you could take an army of 50 women and remove the Indians from Florida.”

The events of December 28th proved otherwise. “We didn’t lose but two Indians in the battle and seven were wounded,” Morrison
said. A third was killed after the battle later in the day.  Morrison says the event honors the people on both sides of the battle: “It’s a great honor [to participate] but there’s also a sadness. Even the Indians sensed that a lot of brave men died that day.”

The Seminoles, he said, “were fighting for Florida–their land–just like Americans have always fought for this land. There’s pride there. And like all wars it’s the good folks on both sides who suffered.”

“When people come up and apologize to me I tell them, ‘Wait a minute. What our ancestors did to each other was a long time ago. You didn’t do it. Let’s understand each other and share our culture.’ Seminoles were no different from anybody else, we had good and bad people.”

IF YOU GO:

When: First weekend in January.

Where: Dade Battlefield State Historic Site near Bushnell. The site is located between I75 and US 301.

Admission: $5.00.  For information: Call 352-793-4781.

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

More Florida Day Trips

bluespring-640

Blue Spring State Park: A Winter Haven for Manatees

The earliest review of Blue Spring gave the place an 18th-century version of thumbs down. Naturalist John Bartram visited Blue Spring in January of 1766, and found a "surprising fountain ... the colour of the sea, [that] smelled like bilge water, tasting sweetish and … [Read More...]

Manatees at Homosassa Springs

Where to Swim with Manatees

CRYSTAL RIVER, FL -- Florida's manatees may be endangered, but they're not difficult to find. There are several ways to see a sea cow in central Florida. Crystal River Manatee Swimming Tours About 200 manatees (about 10 percent of the total manatee population) spend the winter in … [Read More...]

Family Fun on the Rainbow River

Rainbow River Tubing: An Existential Adventure

RAINBOW RIVER STATE PARK, FL -- They say that any dead fish can float downstream. But so what? If we discovered a live fish that managed to float downstream of its own volition, choosing the simple pleasure of idleness on a sunny afternoon above the sisyphean drudgery of fighting the … [Read More...]

Comments

  1. Ross Beasley says:

    I just finished viewing a historical summary on a cable network as recalled by historian, Frank Laumer. It prompted me to this website. I was quite moved by these revelations. The annual reenactment sounds very intriguing also. Thanks for sharing Florida history.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  2. Bobby Dees says:

    I was once a re-enactor in Florida and this was one of my favorite battles because it is done so accurately and is done right at the original battle site. I felt as though I was right there at the time of the original battle. This is a must see re-enactment.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    • Michael Warren says:

      Thanks for the feedback. It is an outstanding reenactment, and I appreciate you stopping by Florida Traveler!

      VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)
      VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)

Speak Your Mind

*